Tuesday, 13 October 2015

Q3 Legal Update 2015

In our last update we focussed on the announcements in the April budget that Government was holding a consultation on the removal of tax relief on travel and subsistence costs and a discussion around the potential reform of IR35.

Over the summer we attended roundtable meetings with HMRC as part of both processes, discussed them with our industry bodies APSCo and REC, and submitted formal written responses setting out RSG’s position. Our assessment of the likely outcome of these processes is as follows:


Travel and subsistence consultation

It seems almost certain that the availability of travel and subsistence tax relief for contractors is going to be significantly reduced. It is highly likely that HMRC will introduce a supervision, direction or control test (SD or C) which means that any contractors who are under SD or C as to ‘how’ they carry out their client site work will not be able to claim tax relief on travel and subsistence costs. The word ‘how’ is the critical one but we believe it will be difficult to apply in practice. The scope of each element of the SD or C test is also extremely wide and contractors will be deemed to be under SD or C unless they can show otherwise.

It also looks very likely that a debt transfer provision will be introduced. This is of potential concern for clients as it would mean that if you provide false information as to whether a contractor is under your SD or C you will be liable for any unpaid tax that results.

We anticipate that when these changes are introduced, contractors will start asking for written confirmation from clients as to whether they are under their SD or C.

It is likely that the outcome of the consultation will be published in November with guidelines to follow. Changes are expected to be introduced in April 2016. We will keep a close eye on developments and keep you informed as matters progress.

IR35 Discussion


This was a much less focussed document. HMRC’s proposals regarding what to do are more generic and unclear although there is again a proposal for a debt transfer i.e. making you, the client, liable for any non-payment of tax by the contractor.

At the HMRC roundtable meeting we attended all of those industry representatives present were extremely vocal about how anti further change they are, particularly given the changes to the dividend rate, the Intermediaries Reporting legislation and changes to personal tax allowances recently introduced.

Despite the above, we consider it likely that a formal consultation document with proposals for reforming IR35 will be issued by HMRC shortly. Again, we will keep you up to date as things progress.


 
Other Legislative Changes

 The Modern Slavery Act 2015

The Modern Slavery Act (“MSA”) is part of the UK's efforts to combat the global issues of forced labour, domestic servitude and human trafficking; it consolidates and develops existing law on the offences of slavery and trafficking.  Leaving aside situations where a corporate may be held criminally responsible for those offences, the key corporate obligation being imposed by the MSA is the duty to prepare an annual slavery and human trafficking statement.  This obligation is particularly significant (and potentially onerous) because it requires businesses to look beyond their own boundaries to understand their worldwide supply chain. The expectation is that they will then, where necessary, exert influence to eradicate any use of slave labour.

The obligation to provide this statement will apply to all commercial organisations that carry on all or part of their business in the UK, supply goods or services and have a total turnover of £36 million or more. The statement must be approved by the Board and signed by a director, and a link to the statement must be included in a prominent place on the home page of the organisation's website.

See more at : http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/30/contents/enacted

 Trade Union Reforms

The government has published the Trade Union Bill 2015-2016 which aims to reform various aspects of the law on industrial action and trade union obligations and activities.  The proposed reforms include increasing ballot thresholds, extending the notice of industrial action required to be given to employers and a new expiry date for action to be taken following a ballot. The Bill would introduce more stringent requirements for unions to supervise picketing. There are also proposals to require public sector bodies or bodies which are publicly funded to publish information about time spent on union activities and to limit the right of union officials to be paid for union time in the public sector.

Tucked away amongst all this is a proposal allowing employers to use agency workers during strikes.  Currently, employment businesses are restricted from providing agency / temporary workers during strike action unless very specific criteria have been met.

The Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 (as amended)


An overhaul of this legislation has been on the cards for some years.  Consultations have taken place, as have numerous round table discussions within the recruitment industry.  However, until now there has been no real appetite to change; will the introduction of the Trade Union Reforms generate this?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Blog Archive