Monday, 14 February 2011

Email Chain or Binding Contract? Hints and Tips

by Karen Ainsworth

The legal bit: a High Court has just ruled that an exchange of emails between two companies could create a binding contract. This is a good reminder to us all to avoid accidentally creating contracts when negotiating by email, as each exchange of email can accept or reject either parties’ points and this can act as a contract in the absence of anything formally signed.

We all recognise that a contract is a signed agreement with terms that are subject to detailed and precise negotiation. However, we should also remember that contracts are still flexible and can be created in a variety of ways. This potentially exposes a real risk that they may be accidentally created when they are not intended.

Dispelling some common myths about creating contracts:

"If I don't sign anything then there cannot be a binding contract"

Only a few specialist contracts (such as guarantees and contracts for the sale of land) need to be signed to be binding. Most types of contracts do not need to be signed or even put in writing but if they are written, then it should be very clear what each party has agreed to.

Even if a signature is required, this does not mean that the signature must be with a pen. "Signature" means voluntarily making one's mark on a document. Stamping a document, placing photocopies of signatures on an agreement and even inserting one's name at the bottom of an email could all be considered signatures.

Safest approach : get it all written down and signed by both parties

"Emails or documents marked "subject to contract" can never form a binding contract"

Marking a document "subject to contract" is a good way to prevent contracts being accidentally created because it creates a presumption that negotiations are continuing and there is more work to be done before a binding agreement is reached. However, if parties start to perform the contract before the formal terms are agreed then this presumption may be overturned and this could result in a partly agreed contract with gaps, where certain issues have not been finalised and its a common area of commercial disputes.

Safest approach : finalise the agreement before starting work. Commercially this may not always be possible but we need to be aware that by starting to carry out our side of the contract we run the risk of waiving the protection offered by the "subject to contract" provision, or losing out on fees.

"All the terms of a contract must be in one place"

Contracts can be spread over several documents but, when the terms of an agreement cannot be found in one place, it makes it very difficult to know what has been agreed.

Safest approach : ensure the agreement contains everything, or very clearly references other documents that are part of the agreement.

"Only directors and senior managers can create contracts that are binding on companies"

Anybody who reasonably represents that they have authority to act on behalf of a company can bind that company to a contract. This person could be an employee or even a third party agent. Authority can be given to a person in writing or by conduct. E.g., an employee that negotiates contracts on behalf of a company but fails to state that they need approval from a more senior manager could be held to have authority to conclude that contract.

Good practice for employees is to make clear (preferably in writing) early in the negotiations that they have no authority to conclude the contract.

Safest approach : make it clear (preferably in writing, such as on email) that you have no authority to conclude the contract – advise the client that their points are being considered / referred to the legal team, etc, so it’s extremely clear that you’re not accepting anything.

"To vary a written contract, the variation must also be in writing"

Contracts can both be varied by a further contract but this can be oral or in writing - the key requirement is that both parties must be giving new promises or fresh consideration for the variation to be legally binding.

Safest approach : put it in writing but … bear in mind that an exchange of emails could be a contract in writing and email sign-offs can amount to signatures.

No comments:

Post a Comment