Friday, 4 February 2011

Is Everybody Caught? - How the AWR may affect Limited Company and Umbrella Company Contractors













By Karen Ainsworth, Legal Services

As a result of the unwieldy IR35 legislation brought into force in 2000, the recruitment industry has seen a rise in the number of contractors choosing to operate as an umbrella company. Now, with the Agency Workers Regulations (“AWR”) due to be implemented in October this year, Resource Solutions Group Plc (“RSG”) believes that the balance between limited company and umbrella company contractors is liable to shift again.

According to the AWR, agency workers contracted via an ‘umbrella company’ or other intermediary will fall within the boundaries of the AWR, but the genuinely self-employed, working through their own limited liability company may be excluded. The definition of “agency worker” for the purpose of the AWR is based on that used in the Working Time Regulations 1998 finding work through a “temporary work agency” (definition based on existing statutory concept of an “employment business”). This means that after 12 weeks continuous ‘employment’, agency workers will have equal treatment; equal treatment is defined as basic working and employment conditions that would apply to agency workers as if they had been recruited directly by the user undertaking “the hirer” to occupy the same job. The AWR does not change the agency worker’s contractual relationship, which remains with the employment business.

Under the AWR, a limited company contractor is a worker who is genuinely ‘in business on their own account’, i.e. self employed. However, the Government has not yet offered any indication of how it will judge whether a contractor is in business on their own account or not, for the purposes of the AWR

Where employment status struggles to be clearly defined, AWR confuses the situation still further. According to www.direct.gov.uk, whether you are employed or self employed depends on the terms and conditions of your working arrangement, so where some contractors will now be entitled to ‘equal treatment’ under the AWR, surely this will significantly muddy the waters?

The definition of an independent contractor is ‘a person hired by another, not as an employee but, rather, pursuant to a contract for service where the engaging party does not supervise or control the detail of the work, and where the party engaged remains self-employed.’ However, until a contractor has started in a new project, how can they judge the level of direct supervision or the amount of control they will have over their work?

There is potential for a hirer to engage two individuals fulfilling identical roles; one of these individuals may be supplied via the employment business as being ‘in business on his/her own account’ but the other individual may be an agency worker via an umbrella company. The hirer may be clear that the roles to be fulfilled are project based, with defined acceptance criteria and deliverables but when looking at the definition of a contractor and an agency worker one will be in business on his own account and one will be under the direction, supervision and control of the hirer. Will the hirer be able to specify to the employment business that he only wants to engage the genuinely self-employed, or will anti-avoidance measures prevent him from doing so?

What happens when the individual supplied by the employment business wishes to change his supply vehicle; employment businesses often face requests from the individual to change from an umbrella company to their own personal service company, or vice versa; how will this now sit with the AWR?

Contractors are already concerned about whether to go down the limited or umbrella route; being in business on your own account can be daunting, as the contractor has to have an understanding of contract law, employment law and tax law in order to be able to judge whether he/she is ‘operating in business on his/her own account’ with such decision being taken prior to a contract being accepted. On the other side of the fence is the option of being employed by an umbrella company, but the contractor must undertake due diligence and understand how the chosen umbrella company operates in line with current legislation before signing up, as if the advertised scheme appears ‘too good to be true’, it probably is!

The Government advises contractors to review the details of their engagement on a contract-to-contract basis, but with many contractors regularly switching between limited companies and umbrella providers, how will this be regulated? I predict we will see a rise in the number of limited company contractors, as many working under umbrellas will be concerned that their work offers will decrease with the advent of the AWR.

The AWR was initially an EU directive aimed to protect the most vulnerable agency workers who were in receipt of low pay and were also at risk of being taken advantage of. However, as it stands many contractors who are actually high earners will fall within the scope of the legislation, which appears to class all workers as ‘vulnerable’. Is the protection of vulnerable workers going to cause a reduction in the flexibility of the UK non permanent resource pool? This is built on a flexible resourcing model which benefits individuals and hirers – would this be at risk?

Equally, what impact will this have on the hirer? Will hirers need to focus more on outcome based solutions in order to differentiate between those within the AWR and those not, or at least change their approach?

These issues are indicative of the Government’s failure to understand contracting in the 21st century labour market. Ultimately, should it be down to employment businesses to make it entirely clear to a contractor the nature of the contract they are being offered and its implications for their rights under the AWR, before it is entered into?

Clients, employment business and contractors alike now avidly await clear guidance and the development of simple procedures for implementation.

-ENDS-

Wednesday, 2 February 2011

RSG Welcomes Clare Marsh

The Compliance Team would like to introduce Clare Marsh as a new starter.

Clare is currently undergoing her training, but she will ultimately be responsible for Lloyds GCM Compliance.

We hope you will all make her feel welcome and assist with her training needs when necessary.

Thanks all.

Monday, 31 January 2011

Contractor Feedback on IR35

During December 2010 and January of this year, RSG approached our contractor base to gain feedback on the Small Business Tax Simplification Review, including the controversial IR35 legislation.
















Common concerns brought to light by contractors included the uncertainty around the application of IR35 and the potential financial impact to small businesses if a decision made by HM Revenue & Customs went against them despite their best efforts to engage on a self-employed basis. Many contractors felt that the disproportionate amount of time and money required to get contracts reviewed could be better spent on business development opportunities. Many felt discouraged from entering the arena, reducing the amount of flexible contracting workers available to the hirer as a consequence.

Karen Ainsworth, Head of Legal at RSG said: “Small businesses inevitably face many problems in a competitive marketplace. Many have to compete against consultancies which employ hundreds of contractors and who can readily deploy staff at short notice. Without having to be concerned about bureaucracy and red tape with regard to assignment specifics, these larger companies have a significant commercial advantage over the small business.

“As an independent operator, the small business has to have an understanding of contract law, employment law and tax law in order to be able to judge whether he/she is ‘operating in business on his/her own account’ and this decision has to be taken prior to a contract being accepted. Often the parties concerned are not entirely sure about contract specifics, save that the hirer has a requirement for specialist skills that are not available within their organisation, and recognise the need to go to market to seek such skills elsewhere.”

Many contractors also reported their concern about pre-engagement vetting.

Karen said: “Some hirers, specifically those in the financial sector, require contractors to have the same on-boarding process, and sign the same policies that are a prerequisite for employees. One contractor was recently so concerned about the similarity between the vetting process for employees and contractors that he actually declined a placement. He was worried about how HM Revenue & Customs would perceive his self-employed status with regard to ‘IR35’ if he has to go through the same vetting as an employee, and sign similar policies such as client security and confidentiality.”

It is feared that the Agency Workers Regulations (“AWR”) due to start on 01 October 2010 may create more uncertainty, as an agency worker will have to be genuinely self-employed, working through their own limited liability company in order to be classed ‘outside’ the scope of the AWR.

Karen said: “Ultimately, having a clear and watertight definition of what ‘genuinely self-employed’ means is fundamental to creating a workable system for ‘IR35’ to move forwards and a framework for other legislation such as the AWR.

“RSG are working alongside employment lawyers and industry bodies to lobby the Office of Tax Simplification to look into the legislation and provide clear and simple guidance for contractors. We recommend addressing the principles of contract law, and the differences between ‘employed’ and ‘self-employed’ as a first priority.”

-ENDS-

Monday, 24 January 2011

RSG Joins GWE Business West

Resource Solutions Group Plc (RSG) has become part of the GWE Business West Initiative, a business and leadership team dedicated to enhancing and developing the South West region.

The Initiative provides a chance for the business community to link with the public sector to ensure that the interests of commerce are taken into account when key decisions are made in the area.

Mike Beesley and Dan Huckle are now affiliated members of the prestigious group, and will meet with like-minded individuals on a regular basis to discuss matters of importance and air views in front of local partnerships and Chamber Committees.

RSG join a community of over 250 other influential organisations, including Aardman Animation, BBC, Bristol News and Media, Airbus UK and the Society of Merchant Venturers. They will work in partnership to support schemes such as the Broadmead Board, Destination Bristol and the Bristol Cultural Development Project in conjunction with Bristol City Council.

Mike said: “RSG is delighted to be involved in the Initiative. Being based in the South West for over 35 years, we have grown into one of the regions leading recruitment providers, and as such, have a vested interest in the area.

“We are especially interested in exploring how investors can be attracted to the West of England, ensuring that enterprise is encouraged across the region and that Bristol is capable of competing in a global marketplace.”

-ENDS-

Monday, 17 January 2011

'Survival of the Fittest' - Why some recruitment businesses will not weather the recovery


Guest Blog by Mike Beesley


2011 is set to be the year that the UK economy turns a corner and rises out of the slump of the recession. Momentum driven by consumers and business is predicted to result in continued economic growth, and GDP is set to grow by 2.1% over the course of the year.

With the markets improving rapidly and conditions remaining favourable, the recruitment industry, which significantly contracted in size during 2009/10, will be expecting to see many companies making a strong comeback. However, the reality is that many will be unable to respond to the upturn and I predict that we will see many recruitment businesses hit the wall in 2011.

David Pattison, senior analyst and author of the 2011 Plimsoll analysis said: "An estimated 250 recruitment businesses are hanging on by the skin of their teeth according to an annual report." He cited the reason for this as: 'falling demand and a refusal to make the appropriate cuts to their operations at the right time.'

Whilst this may be true, there are to my mind two obvious reasons why recruitment businesses will fall at the first hurdle in the race to economic recovery; lack of general business accumen and a shortage in cash flow.

It is easy to set up a recruitment business in a boom market. All you need is a network of good contacts and the ability to respond to supply and demand. Whilst we were operating in an active recruitment market, many independent recruiters set themselves up in business. However, in the midst of a recession it is not enough just to be a good recruiter - you need to be a good business person too.

As well as taking standard measures to improve efficiency and cut operating costs during a downturn, it makes good business sense to diversify your offering into new market sectors. By all means stick to what you know, but investigate supplying those services into areas that remain strong whilst other core markets are contracting.

This latest slump has had a devastating effect on the recruitment industry and every sector of the market has been impacted. However with utilities, social care, financial services and engineering all predicted to be significant growth areas in 2011, it is worth spreading the risk where possible across new market sectors in an effort to strengthen your business.

At RSG, the breadth and depth of our customer base, acquired over the last 35 years, has helped us to stay profitable despite operating in a recessive market. In 2010, RSG posted an impressive £4.9million operating profit with only 130 employees, bouncing back from the recession to significantly grow our gross profit by the end of the year.

Another reason why recruitment firms may struggle to accommodate the market upsurge is because they have cut too deep in an attempt to protect their business in the early stages of the recession. Some companies will be starting the New Year with severely limited resources, and this will hinder their ability to respond to the growing number of clients and vacancies that are out there.

During the recession, RSG made it a priority to protect its workforce, and now have the necessary volume to respond to increased demand where our competitors cannot. We also acquired the staff from a failing recruitment company, putting a roof over their heads whilst strengthening our own bottom line. People are the key assets of any recruitment business, and a company that manages to protect its staff during a difficult financial period will find themselves better placed to respond to opportunities when the economy finally recovers.

Those who have so far relied on their business acumen to keep them afloat may end up sinking in the long run due to a shortage in cash flow. Any ‘immature’ business is likely to have cash-flow issues but it is vital to recognise that revenue streams and survival are intrinsically linked.

By continually investing profits back into the business, RSG has remained cash-rich and therefore able to move swiftly in the face of economic recovery to secure new contracts and clients. Many firms will not have had sufficient revenue to cope with the fall in demand during the recession, and therefore will not be able to fund growth in 2011.

For some businesses, the economic recovery will come much too late, and clients must beware of “solvent insolvency”. However, those who have managed to be commercially successful without jeopardising their financial stability will find they reap the benefits in 2011.

-ENDS-