Monday, 17 January 2011

'Survival of the Fittest' - Why some recruitment businesses will not weather the recovery


Guest Blog by Mike Beesley


2011 is set to be the year that the UK economy turns a corner and rises out of the slump of the recession. Momentum driven by consumers and business is predicted to result in continued economic growth, and GDP is set to grow by 2.1% over the course of the year.

With the markets improving rapidly and conditions remaining favourable, the recruitment industry, which significantly contracted in size during 2009/10, will be expecting to see many companies making a strong comeback. However, the reality is that many will be unable to respond to the upturn and I predict that we will see many recruitment businesses hit the wall in 2011.

David Pattison, senior analyst and author of the 2011 Plimsoll analysis said: "An estimated 250 recruitment businesses are hanging on by the skin of their teeth according to an annual report." He cited the reason for this as: 'falling demand and a refusal to make the appropriate cuts to their operations at the right time.'

Whilst this may be true, there are to my mind two obvious reasons why recruitment businesses will fall at the first hurdle in the race to economic recovery; lack of general business accumen and a shortage in cash flow.

It is easy to set up a recruitment business in a boom market. All you need is a network of good contacts and the ability to respond to supply and demand. Whilst we were operating in an active recruitment market, many independent recruiters set themselves up in business. However, in the midst of a recession it is not enough just to be a good recruiter - you need to be a good business person too.

As well as taking standard measures to improve efficiency and cut operating costs during a downturn, it makes good business sense to diversify your offering into new market sectors. By all means stick to what you know, but investigate supplying those services into areas that remain strong whilst other core markets are contracting.

This latest slump has had a devastating effect on the recruitment industry and every sector of the market has been impacted. However with utilities, social care, financial services and engineering all predicted to be significant growth areas in 2011, it is worth spreading the risk where possible across new market sectors in an effort to strengthen your business.

At RSG, the breadth and depth of our customer base, acquired over the last 35 years, has helped us to stay profitable despite operating in a recessive market. In 2010, RSG posted an impressive £4.9million operating profit with only 130 employees, bouncing back from the recession to significantly grow our gross profit by the end of the year.

Another reason why recruitment firms may struggle to accommodate the market upsurge is because they have cut too deep in an attempt to protect their business in the early stages of the recession. Some companies will be starting the New Year with severely limited resources, and this will hinder their ability to respond to the growing number of clients and vacancies that are out there.

During the recession, RSG made it a priority to protect its workforce, and now have the necessary volume to respond to increased demand where our competitors cannot. We also acquired the staff from a failing recruitment company, putting a roof over their heads whilst strengthening our own bottom line. People are the key assets of any recruitment business, and a company that manages to protect its staff during a difficult financial period will find themselves better placed to respond to opportunities when the economy finally recovers.

Those who have so far relied on their business acumen to keep them afloat may end up sinking in the long run due to a shortage in cash flow. Any ‘immature’ business is likely to have cash-flow issues but it is vital to recognise that revenue streams and survival are intrinsically linked.

By continually investing profits back into the business, RSG has remained cash-rich and therefore able to move swiftly in the face of economic recovery to secure new contracts and clients. Many firms will not have had sufficient revenue to cope with the fall in demand during the recession, and therefore will not be able to fund growth in 2011.

For some businesses, the economic recovery will come much too late, and clients must beware of “solvent insolvency”. However, those who have managed to be commercially successful without jeopardising their financial stability will find they reap the benefits in 2011.

-ENDS-





Thursday, 4 November 2010

Guest Blog by Rob Cooper


Having recruited within the IT + Business Change contracting sector for over 12 years, I can safely say that rate increases at the point of renewal are often a contentious and problematic issue. So I thought I’d play devil’s advocate and look at an issue that I believe is often overlooked by many contractors.

My question is: “Do many contractors consider the potential damage that requesting a rate increase could create?”

I’m not saying that asking for more money at renewal is always going to cause an issue, but I do believe that sometimes a client’s positive opinion of a contractor may reduce when they ask for a hike in their daily rate – especially if their role hasn’t changed, their responsibilities haven’t increased and their workload hasn't grown.

I can (and do) see it from both sides:

- the client doesn’t want to pay any more for a contractor than they currently are paying and don’t like being held to ransom (in their opinion) when a contractor has become business critical,

- and contractors want to ensure their rate is in line with market rates, or what they perceive to be their worth for the services they are providing (this is clearly a hard thing to measure!)

I think the problem often stems from the fact that, for whatever reason, many clients seem to take rate increase requests personally and sometimes hold it against the contractor for asking – whereas contractors see it simply as a business transaction for the provision of services and argue that negotiations like this happen across the globe in all industries.

One of my long-standing contractors (who has worked for me for over 8 years at a number of different clients) has always taken a pragmatic approach to his rate. “Rob, if my rate is a bit lower than most of my colleagues, and I don’t usually ask for increases at renewal, I’ve found that I tend to get renewed for a lot longer than most of my colleagues”. One of his contracts lasted for around four years, whereas the majority of his colleagues who were demanding 30-40% higher rates tended not to last much more than 6-12 months.

Was this due to their rate demands, or just because my contractor is better at his job than the others? Hard to say, but he’s convinced that his easy-going attitude to rates has certainly played its part and he has never been out of work for more than 2 weeks in over 10 years of contracting.

Personally, I think his success is due mostly to him being an excellent Project Manager, but I do believe that his stance around rates has helped.

I guess it depends on your own personal opinion, attitude and ultimately what drives you, as to what approach you adopt.

Many contractors are in the contracting business predominantly for the money, therefore they want to maximise their earning potential and will push their rates as high as they possibly can. If this causes ill feeling with the client, then so be it – they are here to manage and deliver a project for the client, not to make life-long friends!

Others like to work in a friendly, positive atmosphere without any ill-feeling so don’t want to push for a rate increase in the worry that the client might hold it against them.

And others (like my contractor mentioned above) take the pragmatic business approach that he will earn more money in the long-term if he is always in work at a slightly lower rate, rather than have a higher daily rate but risk not get renewed as often and being “out of contract” more often.

Friday, 29 October 2010

Charlie and RSG at the 2010 REC Awards!


Just a little note to say well done to Charlie Grubb for coming “a highly commended” second place in the REC's Executive Recruiter of the Year category at their annual awards bash on Tuesday (he's certainly come a long way since his first job as a hot dog seller in OZ!)

In the words of Kevin Green, REC's Chief Executive,

“Congratulations to everyone who entered. The standard of entries was exceptional. For those of you who were short-listed, bask in the glory of your achievements, the bar was set high.”

Mr Green also commented that the REC's Institute of Recruitment Professionals was extremely proud of the many skilled and dedicated individuals working within our industry and the REC awards were a celebration of excellence and professional pride. He told attendees that the recruitment businesses that succeed in the long term are those that have the most capable, resourceful and creative people and the REC awards were also to recognise the businesses that have invested in them.

I'd like to tell you more about what happened at the Awards ceremony but unfortunately I've been sworn to a 'What happens at the REC Awards, stays at the REC Awards' oath...sorry!

2010 is the first year that we have attempted to enter a few industry awards and polls with the RSG brand and and we are delighted to have come very close to the top spot in a fair few instances, from Best Marketing Campaign in the Recruitment Industry Awards to the BEP's Business of the Year Award.

Mike Beesley added;

"We feel very proud of the RSG brand, our services and our people, and the value they add in the recruitment market. This comes across in the passion we have for delivering the RSG mark of quality and expertise. These accolades only reinforce the fact that we are on the right path and we will continue to make a real difference in the market place."

Friday, 8 October 2010

Sanderson have been announced as a finalist in the Jobsite RecrutRank Awards 2010.



Recognising best practice and customer service in recruitment agencies, the RecruitRank Awards are the only accolades in the industry where finalists and winners are chosen by the feedback from candidates and not a panel of industry judges.

RecruitRank is Jobsite's ground-breaking system that tiers recruitment agencies according to feedback from candidates. If a candidate has applied for a vacancy listed by an agency on Jobsite, they're invited to comment anonymously on four different areas:

  • Overall impression of the agency

  • Maintaining contact and updating you on progress

  • Understanding your needs

  • Knowledge of your industry sector

“The RecruitRank Awards give agencies the chance to celebrate their great customer service and be rewarded for looking after their talent. Not only that, the RecruitRank Awards provide recruitment agencies with real credibility in the eyes of employers looking for that elusive talent and more importantly reassure candidates looking for a recruitment partner they can trust.”

Keith Potts, Managing Director of Jobsite



Tuesday, 28 September 2010

Personality Counts!


Having worked in recruitment for over 12 years, I’ve been responsible for recruiting many different types of candidates for a variety of market sectors, including Software Programmers, Database Architects, ITIL Consultants, Service Delivery Managers and Disaster Recovery Managers, through to Project Managers, Programme Managers, IT Directors etc.

Whilst recruiting for technical positions, finding the ‘ideal’ candidate is certainly an easier 'science'. For example, if I’m looking for a .Net Programmer with strong SQL Server skills, it’s usually fairly obvious form looking at their CV if someone has had this type of experience – the hard part is in finding out how good their technical skills are!

However, when recruiting for non-technical IT Project Managers or Business Project Managers, I’m a big believer that it’s the personal traits of the PM at interview that play a big factor on the hiring manager’s decision.

Whilst the hiring manager is obviously looking for a PM who they believe has the experience to deliver the actual project, in my experience it is often equally as important for the hiring manager to connect with the candidate. For me that means assessing their personality traits and deciding if they have the right personal characteristics to deliver the project.

Whilst a lot of people like to think they can adapt their approach to most situations (and many can, to a point), I honestly believe that some PM’s personalities will be better suited to certain roles, and astute hiring managers will also be looking for these whilst interviewing.

I'll give you an example of two roles I have recently been asked to fill:
The first role is for a PM who will have to manage some very tough and demanding negotiations with a third party supplier. This is likely to require a different type of PM to another project, where the biggest problem they will face is the project team, who have been falling out and failing to work well together.

The first role is likely to require a stronger personality, someone who is comfortable standing up to bullish supplier and can develop a good working relationship with them further down the line - once the supplier has understood that they aren’t going to get everything their own way!

The second role is possibly looking for a PM who has better 'soft skills. Someone who has good people skills and is capable of encouraging the team to discuss their issues and work together and create a positive working environment - ultimately getting the project back on track.

So my role as a recruiter is not only to identify who the good Project Managers are, but also to understand what type of personality traits the hiring manager is looking for and that best fit with the job in hand. This is one of the hardest parts of my job, and in my opinion the best way to get a good understanding of a candidate’s personality is to meet them face to face.

Unfortunately, this isn’t always possible (due to location and time constraints) but I do my best to meet as many of my core contractors as possible and it’s certainly paid dividends to both myself and the candidates – the ratio of people I’ve met and who I’ve placed in a contract is massively higher than those who I haven’t met. The problem I have is that I have to be fairly selective in who I meet, otherwise I’d never get any other work done!!!

By Rob Cooper

Wednesday, 8 September 2010

Common Courtesy is a Valuable Commodity!

Leading on from my last blog about the recruitment process, through the eyes of a 'candidate' , I thought I would carry on with this theme and have clubbed together some helpful hints regarding client and candidate care, and courtesy to all!

Having recently been on the receiving end of some truly terrible customer service, the subject of professional courtesy has been on my mind lately. It seems that some organisations see extending common courtesy as a waste of precious time, unnecessary after the customer has been snared; others mistake it with subservience and weakness.

In my experience extending common courtesy not only helps to oil the wheels of everyone’s working day, it makes us money. It encourages engagement, loyalty and generates the kind of PR that money can’t buy. My point is that treating customers well - and not just those we place or whose jobs you fill - is good business. So how can you do this with limited time and targets to hit?


Respond to all applicants
Yes, all of them. An automated response along the lines of: ‘Thank you for your interest. We shall be in touch within X days if your application is successful’, ensures applicants know their application has been received, and what's happening with it.

If you don’t have time to do that, why waste time and resources advertising for more applicants that you won’t be able to respond to?


Manage people’s expectations
A person who walks away from a meeting with no idea of when or if they’ll hear from you again, is unlikely to feel confident in your abilities or recommend you to others. Ensure clients and candidates know what they can expect from you.

People become frustrated when they feel ignored or uninformed, if you know a client will take two weeks to review applications, manage candidates' expectation. Failure to do so risks them wasting time chasing for updates you don't have, and thinking you're not very good at your job.

Do what you’ve said you’ll do
Clients and candidates appreciate that things don’t always go according to plan, but they’ll respect you more for contacting them with a disappointing update, that if you leave them in the dark. The contact will also give you the opportunity to stay up to date with their situation and potentially generate leads and referrals.


Don’t promise what you know you won’t deliver!
Explain to someone why you can’t assist, and if possible, offer an alternative solution. People may be disappointed, but they’ll respect you for your honesty and advice.


Remember - good manners does not equal subservience
Assertiveness is essential for recruiters. If you’ve a candidate stalking you, don’t ignore them – they’re unlikely to go away. Tell them what level of contact is required, and explain that time spent answering additional calls means less time available to find work for them.


Tackle difficult issues head-on
The slower you are to respond to a complaint or other difficult issue, the more wound-up the person will be when you do eventually speak to them. Diffuse volatile situations as early as you can.

Extending professional courtesy should be an innate part of everything that you do. It makes your – and your customers' – working life easier and acts as a magnet for referrals, leads and revenue.